Cyber-attacks on voting infrastructure. Is there a backup plan?
Imagine that during this upcoming election in November if no results were available until days after the election. On July 31st the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), in conjunction with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) released a public service announcement stating that there is potential for a Distributed Denial of Service (DDOS) attack on election infrastructure and adjacent infrastructure that supports operations.
To better understand the situation, here is some background information. CISA was established in November 2018 to enhance the security, resilience, and reliability of the nation’s critical infrastructure. CISA is at the heart of mobilizing a collective defense to understand and manage risk to our critical infrastructure and associated National Critical Functions. Basically, CISA is charged with protecting US cyberspace as well as the nation’s critical infrastructure such as power, water, and even our elections.
A DDoS attack is a malicious attempt to disrupt the normal traffic of a targeted server, service, or network by overwhelming it with a flood of internet traffic. Hackers do this by using many compromised computer systems as a source of attack traffic. It is like a mob of people rushing to a store to block legitimate customers from shopping. Imagine tens of thousands of computers that have been loaded with malware without the users’ knowledge. Now imagine all those computers running a program at the same time against specific sites making continuous requests against the election infrastructure.
Now back to the announcement from CISA:
“With Election Day less than 100 days away, it is important to help put into context some of the incidents the American public may see during the election cycle that, while potentially causing some minor disruptions, will not fundamentally impact the security or integrity of the democratic process,” said CISA Senior Advisor Cait Conley. “DDoS attacks are one example of a tactic that we have seen used against election infrastructure in the past and will likely see again in the future, but they will NOT affect the security or integrity of the actual election.”
CISA’s intent is to assure the public that the elections will not be affected even though there may be disruptions that may prevent the public from receiving timely information. However, if they know that adversaries may target the elections, how do they know that the elections will be safe and secure? How do they know that a DDoS against the voting tabulation network won’t block results from being collated. How do they keep a breach from occurring in the voting infrastructure? What happens if there is a major regional power outage due to cyber-attack? As we know from the CrowdStrike outage where Maricopa County’s Dominion voting machines got the blue screen of death update (see article from 2 weeks ago for more details), voting machines are on the network. Why would it just be periphery report structure and not the actual voting? As a cybersecurity professional the joint FBI and CISA statement provides more questions than answers.
Perhaps to properly secure the election system, we need to employ the same cybersecurity strategies that businesses use in case of emergencies. There should be contingency plans ready in case of a cybersecurity event. Precincts, counties and states should be ready to manually count the votes for all the races in case of a regional or national cyber-attack. The people required to perform the required functions – counters, watchers, recorders should be prepared and ready. Knowing the risks, should manual counting of paper ballots at the precinct level be the primary method with machine backup?
It seems CISA and the FBI are placating the public and telling us not to worry. Maybe they should spend more resources into hardening the infrastructure and working with the local resources on contingency planning in case of emergency.
This article was originally published in the Sierra Vista Herald found here.